Yesterday: Confucius saw chaos and said, "Fix society."
Today: The Daoists saw chaos and asked, "What if society is the problem?"
Confucian Diagnosis
People forgot proper relationships
Solution: Education, ritual, virtue
More civilization needed
Daoist Diagnosis
People forgot how to live naturally
Solution: Return to simplicity
Less civilization needed
Same Crisis, Different Medicine
Spring and Autumn Period (770–476 BCE)
Remember the context:
Zhou political order collapsing
Warfare between rival states
Traditional values breaking down
Thinkers asking: "What went wrong?"
Confucius: The old ways were good — we just stopped following them.
Daoists: Maybe the "old ways" were never as good as we thought.
What Is "Daoism"?
A Complicated Category
Daoism (also spelled "Taoism") includes:
Philosophical texts (Daodejing, Zhuangzi)
Religious traditions (priests, temples, rituals)
Practices (meditation, alchemy, martial arts)
Folk traditions (gods, spirits, feng shui)
⚠️ Important Corrective:
Western scholars once separated "philosophical Daoism" from "religious Daoism." Current scholarship sees these as intertwined aspects of one tradition.
Laozi — The Old Master
A Legendary Figure
Name means "Old Master" — possibly a title, not a name
Traditional story: archivist who left civilization
Historical person? Probably not — or a composite
What matters: the text, not the biography
📸 Image needed: "Laozi riding ox westward Chinese painting"
Suggested caption: Laozi departing civilization on an ox — legend says he wrote the Daodejing at the western border before disappearing
×
Laozi Legend
According to tradition, Laozi was a royal archivist who, disgusted with civilization's corruption, rode west on an ox. A border guard asked him to record his wisdom before leaving. The result: the Daodejing. Historically dubious, but a great story.
Click for the full legend →
The Daodejing (道德經)
Classic of the Way and Virtue
Compiled 4th–3rd century BCE (not by one author)
About 5,000 Chinese characters — very short
81 brief chapters of poetry and paradox
Most translated Chinese text after the Bible
Key insight: This isn't a philosophical treatise. It's poetry. It's meant to unsettle, not explain.
×
Title Breakdown
Dao (道) = Way/Path De (德) = Virtue/Power Jing (經) = Classic/Scripture
Sometimes written as one word: Daodejing. Older books use Wade-Giles romanization: Tao Te Ching.
What does the title mean? →
Reading the Daodejing
Expect Paradox
"The Dao that can be spoken is not the eternal Dao.
The name that can be named is not the eternal name."
— Daodejing, Chapter 1
This isn't mystical obscurantism. It's making a point: ultimate reality exceeds language.
The moment you define the Dao, you've limited it. The moment you think you've grasped it, it's slipped away.
Quick Check: Orientation
Reflection Questions:
How does Daoist diagnosis of social crisis differ from Confucian diagnosis?
Why is Laozi considered "legendary" rather than historical?
Why does the Daodejing use paradox?
Take 2 minutes to jot answers
Dao (道) — The Way
What Is It?
The Dao is:
The underlying pattern of reality
The source and sustainer of all things
Not a god or supernatural being
Not something you worship — something you align with
"There was something formless yet complete,
that existed before heaven and earth...
I do not know its name; I call it Dao."
— Daodejing, Chapter 25
Characteristics of Dao
What Can We Say?
Dao IS:
Source of all things
Ever-present
Nameless, formless
Accessible through alignment
Dao is NOT:
A creator god
Somewhere "else"
A thing among things
Reached through worship
The challenge: Words fail. Every description is partial. The Dao that can be spoken...
De (德) — Virtue/Power
The Second Key Term
De is often translated as "virtue" but means something specific:
The Dao as expressed in individual things
Each thing's natural potency or power
What makes something authentically itself
Think of it this way:
Dao = the ocean | De = the wave's particular shape
A tree's De is expressed when it grows naturally. Forced into an unnatural shape, its De is damaged.
×
De (Virtue/Power)
Same character as Confucian "virtue" but different meaning. For Confucians, De is cultivated through education. For Daoists, De is innate — you access it by removing artificial obstacles, not by adding knowledge.
Compare to Confucian De →
Wu-Wei (無為) — Non-Action
The Central Practice
Wu-wei literally means "non-action" or "non-doing."
What it does NOT mean:
Laziness or passivity
Doing nothing
Fatalistic resignation
What it DOES mean:
Acting without forcing
Effort without strain
Going with the grain
Wu-Wei: The Water Metaphor
"The highest good is like water.
Water benefits all things and does not compete.
It flows in places people reject and so is like the Dao."
— Daodejing, Chapter 8
Water: Takes the shape of its container. Seeks the lowest place. Overcomes the hard and strong. Never forces, always succeeds.
📸 Image needed: "water flowing around rocks stream nature"
Suggested caption: Water — the Daoist model for effective action — yields to obstacles yet shapes stone over time
Wu-Wei in Practice
Concrete Examples
Forcing (NOT Wu-wei):
Cramming for exams
Micromanaging employees
Arguing someone into agreement
Fighting your emotions
Wu-wei:
Steady daily study
Setting conditions for success
Asking perspective-shifting questions
Acknowledging and releasing
The paradox: Wu-wei often accomplishes more than effortful striving because it doesn't create resistance.
Ziran (自然) — Naturalness
Being "Self-So"
Ziran means "self-so" or "naturalness":
Things being what they naturally are
Acting from authentic nature, not external pressure
Note: Even the Dao "follows" naturalness. Ziran is the ultimate principle.
×
Ziran (Naturalness)
Often translated "nature" but not meaning forests and animals. It means "being so of itself" — things being authentically what they are without external interference. A tree grows by ziran. A person following social convention is not acting from ziran.
What does "naturalness" mean here? →
Concept Application
Scenario (5 minutes):
A student is stressed about choosing a major. Their parents want engineering; their friends are doing business; they secretly love art but worry it's impractical.
How would a Daoist sage advise this student?
Use at least TWO concepts: Dao, De, Wu-wei, or Ziran
Chinese Cosmology: Qi and Yin/Yang
Shared Framework
Before we continue: Qi and Yin/Yang are NOT exclusively Daoist.
These are pan-Chinese cosmological concepts used by:
Daoists and Confucians
Chinese Buddhists
Traditional medicine practitioners
Martial artists
Daoists emphasize: Natural, unforced flow of Qi; balance without interference.
Qi (氣) — Vital Energy
The Stuff of Reality
Qi is:
The vital energy/matter flowing through all things
Neither purely material nor purely spiritual
What animates life and constitutes the cosmos
Can be cultivated, balanced, blocked, or depleted
Applications: Traditional Chinese Medicine, martial arts, feng shui
📸 Image needed: "Chinese medicine Qi meridian diagram human body"
Suggested caption: Qi meridians in traditional Chinese medicine — pathways through which vital energy flows
Yin (陰) and Yang (陽)
Complementary Dynamics
Yin Associations:
Dark, Cool, Receptive
Contracting, Earth
Moon, Rest
Yang Associations:
Light, Warm, Active
Expanding, Heaven
Sun, Movement
📸 Image needed: "Taijitu Yin Yang symbol traditional black white"
Suggested caption: The Taijitu — note the dots showing each contains the seed of its opposite
Understanding Yin/Yang
What It's NOT
⚠️ Important:
Yin/Yang is NOT a moral dualism like good vs. evil
Common Misunderstandings:
❌ Yang is "better" than Yin
❌ Men are Yang, women are Yin
❌ They're opposites that fight
Accurate Understanding:
✓ Both are necessary and valuable
✓ Everything contains both
✓ Health = dynamic balance
Zhuangzi (莊子)
The Second Voice of Daoism
Zhuangzi (traditionally 369–286 BCE):
More playful than the Daodejing
Uses stories, parables, humor
Radical perspectivism — reality looks different from different viewpoints
Celebrates spontaneity and freedom
×
The Text
Like the Daodejing, the book Zhuangzi is composite. The "Inner Chapters" (1-7) are considered most authentically his; "Outer" and "Miscellaneous" chapters are later additions by followers.
About the text →
Zhuangzi's Style
Philosophy Through Story
Where the Daodejing offers cryptic poetry, Zhuangzi offers vivid parables:
A butcher who cuts perfectly because he "follows the Dao"
A swimmer who survives rapids by "going with the water"
Conversations between Zhuangzi and his friend Huizi
The point: Wisdom can't be taught directly. Stories sneak past our defenses.
Zhuangzi's Dream Unveiled
Daoist Philosophy Meets Descartes & Kant
The Butterfly Dream
"Once Zhuang Zhou dreamed he was a butterfly, fluttering about, happy with himself, unaware he was Zhuangzi. Suddenly he awoke, and there he was, solid and unmistakably Zhuangzi. But he didn't know if he was Zhuangzi who had dreamed he was a butterfly, or a butterfly dreaming he was Zhuangzi."
— Zhuangzi, Chapter 2
Discussion: What is this passage really asking about? Just dreams? Or something deeper?
Perspectivism
The Limits of Knowledge
Zhuangzi's point: What you "know" depends on where you stand.
"You are not a fish — how do you know what fish enjoy?"
— Zhuangzi, Chapter 17
Implications:
Human perspective is just one perspective
Our categories and judgments are relative
True wisdom = recognizing the limits of our knowing
The Useless Tree
A Signature Parable
A carpenter passes a huge, gnarled oak tree. His apprentice marvels at it. The carpenter dismisses it: "Useless! The wood is worthless for building."
That night the tree appears in the carpenter's dream: "I've survived precisely because I'm useless. Useful trees get cut down. My uselessness is my protection."
The lesson: What looks like failure by conventional standards might be wisdom by deeper ones.
×
Daoist "Uselessness"
Zhuangzi repeatedly celebrates what society deems worthless — gnarled trees, disabled people, eccentrics. Their "uselessness" by conventional standards frees them from exploitation and allows authentic living.
What does "uselessness" mean here? →
Perspective Exercise
Small Groups (5 minutes):
Your group receives one of these claims:
"Success means having a good career"
"Education should prepare you for the workforce"
"Time spent unproductively is time wasted"
Task: Critique this claim from a Daoist perspective using Zhuangzi's ideas.
Confucianism vs. Daoism
Two Responses Compared
Confucianism:
Fix society through relationships
Cultivate virtue through education
Clear roles and responsibilities
Ritual propriety (Li)
Daoism:
Return to nature, simplify
Remove obstacles to innate nature
Spontaneity and flexibility
Naturalness (Ziran)
Not Either/Or
Chinese Synthesis
"Confucian by day, Daoist by night"
— Traditional Chinese saying
In practice, educated Chinese often:
Used Confucian principles for public/official life
Turned to Daoist ideas for private life, retirement
Saw them as complementary, not contradictory
The question: Can YOU hold both perspectives? Use Confucian discipline when needed, Daoist flexibility when needed?
Day 2 Summary
The Daoist Response:
Same crisis, opposite diagnosis
Society is the problem
Return to naturalness (Ziran)
Stop forcing (Wu-wei)
Key Concepts:
Dao — the underlying Way
De — innate virtue/power
Wu-wei — action without forcing
Ziran — naturalness
Zhuangzi's Contribution: Perspectivism, value of "uselessness," philosophy through story
Preview: Day 3
Historical Developments
Both traditions evolved dramatically over the next 2,000 years.
Coming up:
Mencius and the "moral sprouts"
Confucianism becomes state ideology
Religious Daoism (temples, priests, immortality)
Spread across East Asia
📸 Image needed: "Confucian examination hall Daoist temple China split image"
Suggested caption: Two institutional forms — the Confucian examination system and religious Daoist temples both shaped Chinese civilization