Encountering Daoism

Chapter Seven — Lecture 2

PHIL 210: World Religions

⌨️ Keyboard Shortcuts

What Is "Daoism"?

A Complicated Category

Daoism (also spelled "Taoism") includes:

  • Philosophical texts (Daodejing, Zhuangzi)
  • Religious traditions (priests, temples, rituals)
  • Practices (meditation, alchemy, martial arts)
  • Folk traditions (gods, spirits, feng shui)

⚠️ Important Corrective:

Western scholars once separated "philosophical Daoism" from "religious Daoism." Current scholarship sees these as intertwined aspects of one tradition.

Laozi — The Old Master

A Legendary Figure

  • Name means "Old Master" — possibly a title, not a name
  • Traditional story: archivist who left civilization
  • Historical person? Probably not — or a composite
  • What matters: the Daodejing, not the biography

Legend says Laozi wrote the Daodejing at the western border before disappearing from history.

Click for the full legend →

The Daodejing (道德經)

Classic of the Way and Virtue

  • Compiled 4th–3rd century BCE (not by one author)
  • About 5,000 Chinese characters — very short
  • 81 brief chapters of poetry and paradox
  • Most translated Chinese text after the Bible

Key insight: This isn't a philosophical treatise. It's poetry. It's meant to unsettle, not explain.

What does the title mean? →

Reading the Daodejing

Expect Paradox

"The Dao that can be spoken is not the eternal Dao.
The name that can be named is not the eternal name."

Daodejing, Chapter 1

This isn't mystical obscurantism. It's making a point: ultimate reality exceeds language.

The moment you define the Dao, you've limited it. The moment you think you've grasped it, it's slipped away.

“There was something formless yet complete,
that existed before heaven and earth.
Silent and empty, standing alone and unchanging,
ever present and in motion.
Perhaps it is the mother of all things.
I do not know its name;
I call it Dao.”

Daodejing, Chapter 25

Dao (道) — The Way

The Dao is the fundamental pattern of the universe:

  • Source and sustainer of all things
  • Ineffable—transcends human comprehension
  • Total spontaneity and incessant transformation
  • Not a god to worship, but a way to align with
  • Underlying unity of all existence

De (德) — Virtue/Power

The Second Key Term

De is often translated as "virtue" but means something specific:

  • The Dao as expressed in individual things
  • Each thing's natural potency or power
  • What makes something authentically itself

Think of it this way:

Dao = the ocean   |   De = the wave's particular shape

A tree's De is expressed when it grows naturally. Forced into an unnatural shape, its De is damaged.

Compare to Confucian De →

Wu-Wei (無為) — Non-Action

The Central Practice

Wu-wei literally means "non-action" or "non-doing."

What it does NOT mean:

  • Laziness or passivity
  • Doing nothing
  • Fatalistic resignation

What it DOES mean:

  • Acting without forcing
  • Effort without strain
  • Going with the grain

Ziran (自然) — Naturalness

Being "Self-So"

Ziran means "self-so" or "naturalness":

  • Things being what they naturally are
  • Acting from authentic nature, not external pressure
  • The opposite of artificiality and pretense

"Humanity follows Earth, Earth follows Heaven,
Heaven follows Dao, Dao follows Ziran."

Daodejing, Chapter 25

Note: Even the Dao "follows" naturalness. Ziran is the ultimate principle.

What does "naturalness" mean here? →

Qi (氣) and Yin/Yang (陰陽)

Foundational Concepts in Chinese Thought

Qi — Vital Energy

  • The vital energy/matter flowing through all things
  • Neither purely material nor purely spiritual
  • What animates life and constitutes the cosmos
Qi meridians in traditional Chinese medicine

Yin/Yang — Complementary Dynamics

  • Yin: Dark, Cool, Receptive, Contracting
  • Yang: Light, Warm, Active, Expanding
  • Both are necessary; everything contains both
The Taijitu symbol

Note: These are pan-Chinese concepts, not exclusively Daoist

Zhuangzi: The Second Voice of Daoism

Freedom Through Loosening

  • Zhuangzi (c. 369–286 BCE)
  • Inner Chapters (1–7) — earliest, most authentic
  • Method: stories, humor, paradox
  • Goal: freedom, spontaneity, ease
Traditional depiction of Zhuangzi

Philosophy Through Story

Wu Wei Made Visible

Zhuangzi avoids argument — he shows what wu wei actually looks like in practice.

"I follow the natural structure… I let the knife find its own way."

Cook Ding, Zhuangzi Ch. 3

  • True skill = alignment with natural patterns, not force
  • Stories bypass resistance; insight arises intuitively

The World: Constant Transformation

Hua — The Flow of Things

"Things transform and never return."

Zhuangzi, Ch. 2

  • Reality is a process — nothing fixed or permanent
  • Life, death, gain, loss: phases within a larger flow
  • Suffering arises when we treat temporary states as permanent
Galloping horse symbolizing constant transformation

The galloping horse — Zhuangzi's image of ceaseless transformation

The Self Is Not Fixed

The Butterfly Dream

"Once Zhuang Zhou dreamed he was a butterfly… he didn't know if he was Zhuangzi who had dreamed he was a butterfly, or a butterfly dreaming he was Zhuangzi."

Zhuangzi, Ch. 2

  • Identity is fluid — boundaries between self and world are unstable
  • The self is part of ongoing transformation, not separate from it
  • Spiritual practice: loosen attachment to a rigid sense of who you are

Zhuangzi's Dream — Daoist philosophy meets Descartes & Kant

Distinctions and the Limits of Knowing

This / That — Right / Wrong

"This is also that; that is also this."

Zhuangzi, Ch. 2

  • Human thinking relies on distinctions — useful, but limited
  • Every viewpoint depends on a standpoint
  • Conflict arises when we treat our distinctions as absolute
  • The problem: not knowledge itself, but attachment to being right

The Pivot of the Dao

Shu (樞) — Freedom from Fixation

"The pivot of the Dao… responds endlessly."

Zhuangzi, Ch. 2

  • The pivot is not a "higher" viewpoint — it is the ability to move between perspectives
  • Without becoming trapped in any single one
  • This flexibility is spiritual freedom

The Fish Debate

Zhuangzi vs. Huizi

Huizi: "You are not a fish. How do you know the fish are happy?"

Zhuangzi: "You are not me. How do you know I don't know the fish are happy?"

  • Knowledge depends on standpoint — argument itself becomes the trap
  • Zhuangzi deflects with playful logic, not a counter-argument
  • The lesson: humility and flexibility, not skepticism
Two scholars on a bridge looking down at fish swimming in a clear river, traditional Chinese landscape setting, serene and contemplative mood

Freedom from Social Values

The Useless Tree

"Its uselessness is what keeps it alive."

Zhuangzi, Ch. 1

  • Society prizes usefulness, productivity, service
  • The useless tree survives — "useful" trees are cut down
  • What society rejects may allow freedom from exploitation
  • Daoist wisdom often appears strange or impractical by conventional standards
A massive ancient gnarled oak tree standing alone in a landscape while woodcutters with axes pass by ignoring it, traditional Chinese ink wash painting style

The Ideal: Wandering (You 遊)

"Free and Easy Wandering" — Xiaoyao You

  • Chapter 1 title: Xiaoyao You — "Free and Easy Wandering"
  • The ideal person moves with changing circumstances
  • Without anxiety, rigidity, or fixed destination
  • Freedom = ease within transformation, not control over it
Traditional Chinese shan shui mountain landscape with mist and a small solitary wandering figure dwarfed by vast peaks and empty sky, ink wash painting style evoking Zhuangzi's free and easy wandering

What Zhuangzi Is Really Teaching

Therapeutic, Not Theoretical

Zhuangzi Loosens:

  • Fixed identity
  • Fixed knowledge
  • Fixed social values

The Result:

  • Flexibility
  • Peace and ease
  • Alignment with the Dao

"The sage has no fixed mind."

Zhuangzi, Ch. 7