Islam's presence in India encourages both conversion and creative Hindu response.
Islamic Impact
Conversion to Islam
Monotheistic emphasis
Egalitarian ideals
Hindu Response
Rise of bhakti movements
Devotion to one chosen deity
Sant tradition (poet-saints)
Interfaith dialogue (Kabir, Guru Nanak)
×
Bhakti (Sanskrit: भक्ति)
"Loving devotion" to a personal deity. Bhakti movements emphasized emotional connection to God over ritual and caste hierarchy. Open to all regardless of birth—women, lower castes could participate fully.
The Bhagavad Gita – Setting the Scene
Scripture as Ethical Guide
Part of the Mahabharata epic (100,000 verses)
Dialogue between Prince Arjuna and Krishna
Set on eve of battle between cousins
Functions as a "gospel" within the epic
The Gita's Structure:
18 chapters, ~700 verses
Ch 1-6: Karma Yoga (action without attachment)
Ch 7-12: Bhakti Yoga (devotion to Krishna)
Ch 13-18: Jnana Yoga (knowledge of reality)
Ch 11 (middle): Krishna's divine revelation
📸 Image needed: "Arjuna Krishna battlefield Kurukshetra Bhagavad Gita chariot"
Suggested caption: Krishna counsels Arjuna on the battlefield of Kurukshetra
Arjuna's Dilemma
To fight or not to fight?
The Conflict
Warrior dharma: must fight
Fighting kin destroys families
Violates ahimsa (non-harm)
All choices seem morally wrong
The Paralysis
"My limbs sink, my mouth is parched"
"My body trembles"
"I see no good in killing my kinsmen"
Prefers to die rather than fight
Have you ever faced a situation where any choice seemed wrong? How did you decide?
×
Dharma (Sanskrit: धर्म)
Duty, righteousness, cosmic law. In Hinduism, dharma varies by caste, life stage, and situation. A warrior's dharma differs from a priest's dharma. Arjuna's caste duty as kshatriya (warrior) is to fight.
×
Ahimsa (Sanskrit: अहिंसा)
Non-violence, non-harm. Central ethical principle in Hinduism, Buddhism, and Jainism. Extends to all living beings. Gandhi made ahimsa cornerstone of political resistance. Creates tension with warrior dharma.
Ethical Dilemma Analysis
Small Group Exercise (8 minutes)
List all of Arjuna's obligations (family, caste, kingdom, dharma)
Identify which obligations conflict
What would YOU advise Arjuna to do?
What ethical frameworks could help?
Share Out: Each group presents their analysis (2 min each)
Krishna Instructs Arjuna
Initial Arguments
Must fulfill warrior dharma (Gita 2:31, 33)
Running would bring dishonor (Gita 2:3)
The soul is eternal—killing the body doesn't kill the true self
Death is like changing clothes for the eternal atman
"The wise grieve neither for the living nor the dead"
"The eternal in man cannot kill; the eternal in man cannot die. Unborn, eternal, everlasting, this ancient one is not killed when the body is killed."
— Bhagavad Gita 2:19-20
Arjuna's Response: Still unconvinced. Needs deeper teaching.
×
Atman (Sanskrit: आत्मन्)
The eternal Self, soul, or consciousness within each being. Identical with Brahman (ultimate reality). Survives death and transmigrates through samsara. Central teaching of Upanishads: "Atman is Brahman."
Krishna's Divine Revelation
The Universal Form (Vishvarupa)
Chapter 11: Krishna reveals his cosmic form to Arjuna
Krishna shows vishvarupa—all gods, worlds, beings in him
Arjuna sees past, present, future simultaneously
Vision includes creation and destruction (terrifying and beautiful)
"I am become Death, destroyer of worlds" (Gita 11:32)
"If the radiance of a thousand suns were to burst into the sky, that would be like the splendor of the Mighty One."
— Bhagavad Gita 11:12
📸 Image needed: "Krishna Vishvarupa universal form Arjuna Bhagavad Gita"
Suggested caption: Traditional depiction of Krishna's universal form (vishvarupa) from Chapter 11
×
Vishvarupa (Sanskrit: विश्वरूप)
"Universal form" or "all forms." Krishna's revelation of his cosmic nature containing all beings, gods, worlds, and time itself. Theological climax of Gita—proves Krishna is supreme deity (Vishnu/Brahman), not merely charioteer. Overwhelming vision causes Arjuna both terror and devotion.
Theological Significance
What the Vision Reveals
Krishna's True Nature
Not just human avatar—supreme God
Contains all gods (Brahma, Shiva, Indra)
Source of creation and destruction
Arjuna's Response
Terror: "My mind trembles with fear"
Awe: Prostrates himself in worship
Surrender: "Tell me what I must do"
The vision proves Krishna's authority—not philosophical argument but divine self-disclosure. Arjuna must trust God's commands even when reason fails.
Karma Yoga: The Path of Action
Krishna's Solution
Karma Yoga: Act without attachment to results
Fulfill your dharma (caste duty)
Act with full effort and skill
But renounce attachment to outcomes
Offer all actions to Krishna (devotional surrender)
Results beyond your control—focus on duty, not fruits
"You have a right to perform your prescribed duty, but you are not entitled to the fruits of action. Never consider yourself the cause of the results of your activities, and never be attached to not doing your duty."
— Bhagavad Gita 2:47
The Logic of Nonattached Action
The Problem
Attachment creates karma
Karma binds you to samsara
Desire for results = bondage
Even good deeds create karma
The Solution
Act but without selfish desire
Perform duty as offering to God
Accept results with equanimity
Action becomes worship, not bondage
"The wise see knowledge and action as one; they see truly." (Gita 4:18)
×
Karma (Sanskrit: कर्म)
Action and its consequences. The law of cause and effect—every action leaves residue affecting future births. Good karma → better rebirth. Bad karma → worse rebirth. BUT even good karma binds you to samsara. Liberation requires transcending all karma.
×
Samsara (Sanskrit: संसार)
The cycle of birth, death, and rebirth. Driven by karma. Characterized by suffering (even pleasant births are temporary). Goal: Escape samsara entirely through moksha (liberation). Shared concept across Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism.
Applying Karma Yoga
Reflection Exercise (10 minutes)
Think of a situation where you feel anxious about outcomes (exam, job interview, relationship decision):
What would it mean to act with full effort but without attachment to results?
How might this reduce stress or anxiety?
What's difficult about this approach?
Does this seem like genuine wisdom or just passivity?
Pair-Share: Discuss with a partner (5 min)
Critical Analysis of the Gita
Tensions and Problems
Liberating ethics: Karma yoga offers freedom within duty
BUT: Also reinforces caste hierarchy and warrior violence
Krishna tells Arjuna fighting is his dharma as a kshatriya
Gita explicitly endorses caste system (Gita 4:13, 18:41-44)
Can liberating philosophy coexist with oppressive social structure?
The Paradox: Most beloved Hindu scripture contains both profound wisdom and troubling social conservatism.
Gandhi's Reinterpretation
Allegorical Reading for Modern Ethics
Traditional Reading
Literal battlefield—Kurukshetra
Warrior must fulfill caste duty
Endorses righteous warfare
Supports varna system
Gandhi's Reading
Allegorical—internal spiritual struggle
Battle = fight against evil within
Rejects violence, affirms ahimsa
Universal ethics, not caste-specific
⚠️ Context Matters: While the Gita uses war as its setting, this doesn't mean Hinduism glorifies violence—context and interpretation matter!
Gandhi: "I do not believe the Gita teaches violence for doing good... Under the guise of physical warfare, it described the duel that goes on in our hearts."
Contemporary Hinduism: Three Major Developments
21st Century Transformations
1. Hindu Nationalism (Hindutva)
Political movement asserting Hindu identity in Indian state
2. Dalit Resistance
Challenging caste from within and outside Hinduism
3. Global Diaspora
Hinduism adapting to Western contexts
Each represents different vision of Hinduism's future—tradition vs. reform, nationalism vs. pluralism, hierarchy vs. equality.
Hindu Nationalism (Hindutva)
Political Hinduism in Modern India
Hindutva = "Hinduness" (V.D. Savarkar, 1923)
Defines Indian identity as inherently Hindu
BJP (Bharatiya Janata Party) main political vehicle
Won landslides: 2014, 2019, 2024 (Modi as PM)
Promotes Hindu cultural nationalism, cow protection, temple construction
Supporters Say
Reclaims Hindu dignity after colonialism
Protects Hindu culture
Strong leadership, economic growth
Critics Say
Democratic erosion (press freedom, courts)
Minority persecution (Muslims, Christians)
Vigilante violence (cow-related lynchings)
⚠️ Important Distinction: Hindutva ≠ Hinduism. Many Hindus (including scholars, activists, religious leaders) reject Hindu nationalism as a distortion of their tradition's pluralism.
Dalit Resistance: Ambedkar's Legacy
Challenging Caste from Within and Without
Dr. B.R. Ambedkar (1891-1956)
Born Dalit, faced severe discrimination
Educated abroad (PhD Columbia, law LSE)
Chief architect of Indian Constitution
Concluded: Caste is intrinsic to Hinduism, not reformable
The 1956 Mass Conversion
October 14, 1956: Ambedkar + 500,000 Dalits convert to Buddhism
Largest religious conversion in modern history
Rejects Hinduism as inherently oppressive
"I was born a Hindu, but I will not die a Hindu"
×
Dalit (दलित)
"Oppressed" or "broken." Preferred term over "untouchable" or Gandhi's "Harijan" (children of God). Approx. 200+ million Dalits in India today (~16% of population). Excluded from caste system entirely—considered polluting. Face ongoing violence, discrimination, economic marginalization.
Hinduism and Social Justice
Contemporary Debates
Caste and Gender
Affirmative action (reservation) debates
Inter-caste marriage taboos persist
Women temple priests (controversial)
Sabarimala case (2018): Women's entry
LGBTQ+ and Environment
Section 377 decriminalized (2018)
Hijra (third gender) tradition
Sacred rivers cleanup campaigns
Tree worship environmental activism
How do religious traditions balance preserving core teachings with adapting to modern values? Who decides what's "core" vs. "cultural accretion"?
Workshop: Creating Your Own Synthesis
Integration Activity
Individual Reflection (10 min)
Using concepts from Hinduism, write about:
What is your understanding of ultimate reality?
What is the deepest aspect of yourself?
What "path" appeals most: knowledge, action, devotion, or meditation?
How might "nonattached action" apply to your life?
What Hindu concept do you find most challenging?
Small Group Sharing (15 min)
Share one insight from your reflection
Identify common themes across responses
Discuss: What Hindu concepts seem most relevant today?
Closing Connections
Three Takeaway Lines
Historical: From Indus Valley fertility cults to Vedic sacrifice to Upanishadic philosophy to bhakti devotion to modern reformulations—4,500 years of continuity and change.
Social: From caste and dharma to modern debates over social justice—tensions between tradition and equality, hierarchy and human rights.
Personal: From the Gita's nonattached action to modern questions about vocation and activism—how to act without being enslaved by outcomes.
The Paradox of Hinduism:
Liberating philosophy (Atman = Brahman) + oppressive social system (caste)
Radical inclusivity (many paths) + hierarchical exclusion (untouchability) This isn't inconsistency—it's the complexity of a 4,000-year-old living tradition
Chapter Synthesis and Assessment
Final Reflection Paper (choose ONE):
Compare Hindu moksha with "salvation"/"liberation" in another tradition. Different diagnoses? Different solutions?
Analyze how the Bhagavad Gita addresses ethical dilemmas. Is karma yoga satisfying? Why or why not?
Evaluate whether caste is essential to Hinduism or a historical addition that can be reformed/removed.
Assess Ambedkar's claim that Buddhism offers what Hinduism cannot: genuine equality. Is this fair to Hinduism?
Peer Review
Exchange papers for feedback on thesis clarity, Hindu concepts usage, fair representation, personal insight, evidence-based argumentation.
Looking Ahead: Buddhism
Next Chapter Preview
Buddha's Critique
Rejects caste (birth hierarchy)
Rejects Brahmin ritual monopoly
Rejects Vedic authority
Key Differences
Anatman (no-self) vs. Atman
Nirvana vs. Moksha
Different path, similar goal?
Questions to Ponder:
What happens when a reform movement becomes a separate religion?
How do "child" religions relate to "parent" traditions?
Can you accept karma/rebirth without accepting Hinduism?
If there's no self, who is reborn? Who achieves nirvana?
Homework: Complete reflection paper and read Buddhism chapter introduction