The Gathering Tempest

Chapter 14: 1853-1860

Three Lectures on America's Path to Civil War

Lecture 1

Kansas, the Republican Party, and the Immigration Crisis

50 minutes

14-1: Kansas and the Rise of the Republican Party

14-1a: The Kansas-Nebraska Act (1854)

  • Stephen Douglas proposes organizing Nebraska territory to promote a transcontinental railroad through Chicago
  • Territory lies above the 36Β°30' Missouri Compromise line, forcing a new deal over slavery
  • Douglas's solution: popular sovereignty – let territorial voters decide on slavery
  • "Fatal clause": Act declares the Missouri Compromise "inoperative and void," not merely expired
  • Northerners see this as evidence of a growing Slave Power conspiracy to nationalize slavery

Breaking the Missouri Compromise

  • Missouri Compromise (1820) drew a 36Β°30' line that helped maintain sectional peace for 34 years
  • Became part of a broader "compromise tradition" (1820, 1833, 1850) that many Northerners treated as quasi-constitutional
  • Kansas-Nebraska Act opened this territory to slavery via popular sovereignty, overturning earlier understandings
  • Many Northerners saw this as a betrayal of a "sacred compact" and a change in the rules without their consent
  • Backlash sparked "Anti-Nebraska" coalitions that united previously divided Northern factions

14-1b: Death of the Whig Party

  • Whigs had been the party of the American System and national economic integration
  • Kansas-Nebraska Act split Whigs: Northern Whigs opposed slavery expansion; Southern Whigs backed popular sovereignty
  • Party could no longer function as a national coalition and effectively collapsed by 1856
  • Collapse created a political vacuum in the North
  • Former Whig voters drifted toward Nativism (Know-Nothings) or the new Republican Party

Birth of the Republican Party

  • Founded in 1854 as a direct response to the Kansas-Nebraska Act
  • Coalition of anti-slavery Whigs, Free-Soilers, anti-Nebraska Democrats, and some disillusioned Know-Nothings
  • Core platform: stop the extension of slavery into the territories
  • Exclusively Northern party – the first major sectional party in American history
  • Rallied around "Free Soil, Free Labor, Free Men" and a critique of the South's entire social system

14-2: Immigration and Nativism

Mass Immigration Begins

  • 1840-1860: roughly 4 million immigrants (especially Irish and Germans) arrive
  • Many fill low-wage jobs in port cities, contributing to urban poverty and slums
  • Helps create a new urban working class that cuts across ethnic lines
  • Coincides with collapse of the artisan master–apprentice system into wage labor
  • Rapid change leaves many native-born Protestants feeling under cultural and economic "siege"

14-2a: Immigrants in Politics

  • Immigrants quickly learn to use the political system in their own defense
  • Irish become central to urban Democratic machines, trading votes for jobs and assistance
  • German Forty-Eighters import liberal, antislavery ideals and often gravitate to the Republican Party
  • Both groups oppose nativist restrictions and mobilize against anti-immigrant laws
  • Parties court immigrant votes, while Republicans struggle to balance anti-slavery with a nativist wing

14-2b: The Rise of the Know-Nothings

  • Officially the American Party; nickname "Know-Nothing" from members' secretive replies
  • Strongly anti-immigrant and anti-Catholic; core expression of nativism
  • Push to restrict immigration, officeholding, and lengthen naturalization (e.g., 21-year waiting period)
  • Draw major support from former Whigs and native-born workers who fear job competition and Catholic power
  • Serve as a political "halfway house" for voters hostile to Democrats but wary of Republicans' focus on slavery

Anti-Catholicism and Violence

  • Protestant laborers feel economically and culturally threatened by Catholic immigrants
  • Anti-Catholicism often framed as patriotic defense of republican self-government against Papal tyranny
  • Sensational works (Lyman Beecher’s A Plea for the West, Maria Monk’s fabrications) fuel fears
  • Bible Riots over school Bibles lead to mobs destroying Catholic churches and killing several people
  • Conflicts over public schools help spur a separate Catholic parochial school system

14-2c: The Decline of Nativism

  • Know-Nothing Party peaks quickly around 1854–1855
  • Party splits over Kansas-Nebraska and how to handle slavery
  • Slavery and sectional crisis overshadow immigration as the central political issue
  • Many Northern Know-Nothings drift into the Republican Party
  • By 1860, nativism is subordinated to the crisis over Union and the "Slave Power"

14-3: Violent Conflict in the 1850s

14-3a: Bleeding Kansas

  • Pro-slavery and anti-slavery settlers rush into Kansas, each trying to control territorial elections
  • Border Ruffians from Missouri cross over to stuff ballot boxes and intimidate free-state voters
  • Two rival governments and constitutions emerge: Topeka (free) vs. Lecompton (slave)
  • Popular sovereignty collapses into fraud, intimidation, and guerrilla warfare, with over 200 deaths
  • Federal recognition of the Lecompton regime plus the Sack of Lawrence (1856) convince many Northerners that Washington is complicit and help radicalize John Brown

14-3b: The Caning of Sumner (1856)

  • Senator Charles Sumner (MA) delivers fiery "Crime Against Kansas" speech attacking Senator Andrew Butler
  • May 22, 1856: Representative Preston Brooks (Butler's cousin) enters the Senate chamber and beats Sumner with a cane
  • Sumner suffers severe injuries; Massachusetts leaves his Senate seat empty for years as a symbol of Southern brutality
  • Episode exposes clash between Northern "politics of conscience" and Southern "politics of honor"
  • North hails Sumner as martyr to "Slave Power" violence; South celebrates Brooks as a hero and sends him gift canes

End of Lecture 1

Next: The Election of 1856 and Economic Tensions

The Irish Immigration

  • Great Famine (1845-1850) drives over 1 million Irish to flee starvation
  • Arrive as poor, Catholic refugees, often traumatized and malnourished
  • Cluster in coastal cities, taking low-paid, dangerous jobs and encountering intense discrimination
  • Forge strong ties with urban Democratic machines that offer jobs and protection from Protestant reformers
  • Often anti-abolitionist and fiercely protective of status above free Black workers, even as they slowly climb the social ladder

The German Immigration

  • Diverse group in religion and class, including many "Forty-Eighters" fleeing failed 1848 revolutions
  • Settle heavily in the Midwest (Wisconsin, Missouri, Texas), bringing skills and capital
  • Form tight-knit communities that maintain German language and customs, provoking nativist suspicion
  • "Continental Sunday": beer gardens and family leisure clash with strict Protestant sabbatarian laws
  • Many Forty-Eighters bring liberal, antislavery politics and become important Republican supporters

Lecture 2

The Election of 1856 and Economic Tensions

50 minutes

14-4: The Election of 1856

The Election of 1856

  • First presidential election for Republican Party
  • Republicans nominate John C. FrΓ©mont ("Free Soil, Free Men, FrΓ©mont")
  • Democrats nominate James Buchanan (Pennsylvania)
  • Know-Nothings nominate Millard Fillmore
  • Buchanan wins with Southern + Northern conservative support
  • Republicans carry most Northern states despite loss
  • Demonstrated Republicans could win presidency with North alone

14-4a: The Dred Scott Case (1857)

  • Dred Scott: enslaved man who lived in free territory
  • Sued for freedom based on residence in free state
  • Case reached Supreme Court in 1856
  • Chief Justice Roger Taney delivered 7-2 majority opinion
  • March 1857: Court's explosive decision announced

Dred Scott Decision

  • 1. African Americans could not be citizens
  • Founders never intended Black people to be citizens
  • "beings of an inferior order" with "no rights which the white man was bound to respect"
  • 2. Congress could not prohibit slavery in territories
  • Missouri Compromise unconstitutional
  • Slaveholders' property rights protected by Constitution
  • 3. Residing in free territory did not make Scott free

Impact of Dred Scott Decision

  • Outraged Northern public opinion
  • Invalidated Republican platform (no slavery in territories)
  • Seemed to prove existence of "Slave Power conspiracy"
  • Made popular sovereignty unworkable
  • Strengthened Republican Party rather than weakening it
  • Convinced many Northerners that slavery threatened their own freedom
  • South celebrated but it was a pyrrhic victory

14-4b: The Lecompton Constitution (1857)

  • Pro-slavery Kansas government drafts constitution
  • Lecompton Constitution protected slavery in Kansas
  • Free-state settlers boycotted the referendum
  • President Buchanan urged Congress to admit Kansas as slave state
  • Stephen Douglas broke with Buchanan over fraudulent process
  • Congress rejected Lecompton Constitution
  • Kansas remained in territorial limbo

14-5: The Economy in the 1850s

14-5a: "The American System of Manufactures"

  • Interchangeable parts revolutionized production
  • Specialized machinery replaced skilled craftsmen
  • Allowed mass production of complex goods
  • First developed in firearms manufacturing
  • Spread to clocks, sewing machines, agricultural equipment
  • Made American manufacturing competitive with Britain
  • Created new working class of machine operators

14-5b: The Southern Economy

  • Remained overwhelmingly agricultural
  • Cotton production dominated Southern economy
  • Less industrial development than North
  • Capital invested in land and slaves, not factories
  • Limited railroad development
  • Dependent on Northern industry for manufactured goods
  • Economic structure reinforced social and political conservatism

14-5c: The Sovereignty of King Cotton

  • - James Henry Hammond
  • Cotton comprised 60% of U.S. exports by 1860
  • Southern cotton essential to British textile industry
  • Southerners believed cotton gave them economic leverage
  • Confidence: Britain would support Confederacy to preserve cotton supply
  • Cotton production tied directly to slavery's expansion
  • Cotton economy gave South false sense of security

14-5d: Labor Conditions in the North

  • Long working hours (12-14 hours per day)
  • Dangerous conditions, especially in factories
  • Low wages, particularly for immigrants
  • Child labor common in textile mills and coal mines
  • No government regulations on workplace safety
  • Workers had little job security
  • Growing class consciousness among workers

14-5e: The Panic of 1857

  • Financial crisis began in summer 1857
  • Caused by over-speculation in railroads and land
  • Banks failed, businesses collapsed
  • Unemployment soared in Northern cities
  • International grain prices fell
  • Cotton prices remained relatively stable
  • South seemed to weather crisis better than North

14-5f: Sectionalism and the Panic

  • North suffered more than South from Panic
  • Southerners saw this as proof of slavery's superiority
  • "Cotton is King" rhetoric intensified
  • North demanded protective tariffs and internal improvements
  • South opposed tariffs as favoring Northern industry
  • Economic policy became increasingly sectional
  • Panic exposed deep structural differences between regions

14-5g: Free-Labor Ideology

  • Central belief of Republican Party
  • Free labor superior to slave labor
  • Every man should own his own labor
  • Social mobility possible through hard work
  • Slavery threatened free labor system
  • Republicans championed "Free Soil, Free Labor, Free Men"
  • Appealed to Northern workers, farmers, and middle class

14-5h: The Impending Crisis (1857)

  • Book by Hinton Rowan Helper, a North Carolinian
  • Argued slavery hurt Southern economy
  • Compared North and South economically
  • Claimed slavery benefited only large planters
  • Hurt non-slaveholding whites economically
  • Banned in most Southern states
  • Republicans distributed it widely in North

14-5i: Southern Nonslaveholders

  • 75% of Southern whites owned no slaves
  • Most were small farmers on marginal land
  • Some were skilled craftsmen or laborers
  • Many aspired to own slaves someday
  • Supported slavery for racial and social reasons
  • Slavery elevated all whites above all blacks
  • Fear of slave rebellion unified whites across class lines

End of Lecture 2

Next: Lincoln-Douglas Debates and John Brown

Lecture 3

The Lincoln-Douglas Debates and John Brown's Raid

50 minutes

14-6: The Lincoln-Douglas Debates

Background: Illinois Senate Race (1858)

  • Abraham Lincoln challenges Stephen Douglas for Senate
  • Douglas: nationally prominent Democrat, "Little Giant"
  • Lincoln: relatively unknown Republican lawyer
  • Race attracted national attention
  • Represented larger conflict between North and South
  • Both candidates agreed to series of public debates

Lincoln's "House Divided" Speech

"A house divided against itself cannot stand. I believe this government cannot endure permanently half slave and half free. I do not expect the Union to be dissolved; I do not expect the house to fall; but I do expect it will cease to be divided. It will become all one thing, or all the other."
β€” June 16, 1858
  • Delivered accepting Republican nomination
  • Argued current course unsustainable
  • Slavery would either expand everywhere or be placed on path to extinction

The Lincoln-Douglas Debates

  • Seven debates across Illinois (August-October 1858)
  • Each debate lasted three hours
  • Huge crowds attended (10,000-15,000 people)
  • Focused on slavery in territories and Dred Scott
  • Douglas defended popular sovereignty
  • Lincoln attacked slavery as morally wrong
  • Both opposed full racial equality (typical of era)

Key Issues in the Debates

  • Douglas: Popular sovereignty lets people decide
  • Lincoln: Slavery morally wrong, must be contained
  • Douglas: Slavery will die naturally if not protected
  • Lincoln: Dred Scott shows slavery expanding
  • Douglas: Republicans are radical abolitionists
  • Lincoln: Democrats part of "Slave Power conspiracy"

14-6a: The Freeport Doctrine

  • Freeport, Illinois debate (August 27, 1858)
  • Lincoln posed dilemma to Douglas:
  • Could territories exclude slavery despite Dred Scott decision?
  • Douglas's response: "Freeport Doctrine"
  • Slavery needs positive local regulations to exist
  • Territories could exclude slavery by refusing protective laws
  • This preserved popular sovereignty despite Dred Scott

Impact of the Freeport Doctrine

  • Helped Douglas win re-election in Illinois
  • Satisfied Northern voters who opposed slavery extension
  • Outraged Southern Democrats
  • South saw it as betrayal of Dred Scott
  • Made Douglas unacceptable as presidential candidate to South
  • Contributed to Democratic split in 1860
  • Lincoln lost battle but won the war

Results of the 1858 Election

  • Douglas won Senate seat (state legislature chose senators)
  • Republicans won popular vote in Illinois
  • Lincoln emerged as national Republican figure
  • Debates were published and widely read
  • Lincoln's arguments shaped Republican thinking
  • Set stage for Lincoln's 1860 presidential nomination

14-6b: John Brown at Harpers Ferry

John Brown: Background

  • Born 1800 in Connecticut; raised in Ohio
  • Father was abolitionist and Oberlin College trustee
  • Failed at various businesses: tanner, farmer, wool merchant
  • Moved to North Elba, NY - community for free blacks
  • Became obsessed with taking direct action against slavery
  • 1855: Followed sons to Kansas Territory

Pottawatomie Creek Massacre (1856)

  • May 21, 1856: Pro-slavery forces sack Lawrence, Kansas
  • Brown concluded he had "divine mission" for vengeance
  • May 24, 1856: Brown led nighttime raid
  • Five pro-slavery settlers dragged from cabins
  • Hacked to death with broadswords
  • Brown became "Old Osawatomie Brown"
  • Name conjured fear among slavery supporters

Significance of Pottawatomie

  • Initiated South's view of North as rabid abolitionists
  • Changed terms of slavery struggle
  • Abolitionists previously seen as cowardly
  • Now seen as dangerous, violent criminals
  • Aroused new emotion: FEAR
  • "The ruffians entertain a wholesome dread of Captain Brown"
  • Set stage for Brown's eventual "martyrdom"

Planning the Raid

  • Spring 1858: Brown convened meeting in Chatham, Ontario
  • Announced plan for mountain stronghold for escaped slaves
  • Drafted "provisional constitution" for free territory
  • Gained financial support from Boston abolitionists
  • funded his operations
  • Summer 1859: Prepared for raid on federal arsenal

Raid on Harpers Ferry (October 16, 1859)

  • Brown rented farmhouse across from Harpers Ferry, Virginia
  • Federal arsenal contained thousands of weapons
  • Night of October 16: Brown with 16 whites, 5 blacks attacked
  • Quickly captured arsenal and armory
  • Took 60 leading citizens as hostages
  • Expected enslaved people to join rebellion
  • Hoped to spark "army of emancipation"

Defeat and Capture

  • Local militia surrounded Brown's forces
  • President Buchanan sent U.S. Marines
  • Colonel Robert E. Lee commanded Marines
  • October 18: Marines stormed engine house
  • Brown wounded, 10 followers killed (including 2 sons)
  • Raid lasted only 36 hours
  • Brown captured and imprisoned

Trial and Execution

  • Tried in Virginia state court
  • Charges: murder, slave insurrection, treason against Virginia
  • Brown conducted himself with dignity
  • Gave eloquent defense of his actions
  • Convicted and sentenced to hang
  • December 2, 1859: Brown executed
  • Final note: predicted war and bloodshed to end slavery

The Martyrdom of John Brown

  • Moved boundary of acceptable thoughts about slavery
  • Captured national attention like no other abolitionist
  • Willingness to die had tremendous moral force
  • "John Brown's Body" became Union marching song
  • Inspired "Battle Hymn of the Republic"
  • Northern sympathy shocked and outraged South
  • Brown became symbol of antislavery cause

Southern Reaction

  • Confirmed worst fears about Northern intentions
  • Saw Republicans as embodiment of Brown's views
  • Convinced many that Union was dangerous
  • Secession sentiment increased dramatically
  • Northern sympathy for Brown seemed proof of hostility
  • White Southerners felt security threatened
  • Made sectional compromise increasingly impossible

Victor Hugo on John Brown

"The gaze of Europe is fixed at this moment on America... [Hanging Brown] will open a latent fissure that will finally split the Union asunder. The punishment of John Brown may consolidate slavery in Virginia, but it will certainly shatter the American Democracy. You preserve your shame but you kill your glory."
β€” Victor Hugo, December 1859

The Road to War

Oct 1859 John Brown's raid
Apr 1860 Democratic Convention split
Nov 1860 Lincoln elected
Dec 1860 South Carolina secedes
Feb 1861 Confederate States formed
Apr 1861 Fort Sumter attacked - Civil War begins

Conclusion: The Gathering Tempest

  • Kansas-Nebraska Act shattered sectional compromise
  • Massive immigration created new social tensions
  • Violence moved from territories to Congress to federal arsenals
  • Dred Scott decision eliminated legal basis for compromise
  • Economic differences reinforced sectional identities
  • Lincoln-Douglas debates defined incompatible visions of America
  • John Brown made slavery a moral crisis requiring immediate resolution

By 1860, the American political system had failed to contain the slavery controversy. War was no longer a distant possibility but an approaching certainty.