Discourse

An Analytical Tool

Discourse is the system of language, ideas, and rules that a society uses to define what is true, normal, and possible. It shapes both how we think and how power operates. Discourse is a system of knowledge-production that shapes what can be said, thought, and known about a subject

Example: "Scientific racism" wasn't just prejudice—it was a discourse that organized research questions, institutional practices, and policy decisions around the assumption of racial hierarchy

Manifest Destiny as Discourse

Not just an idea—a knowledge system that made expansion feel inevitable

  • Naturalized violence — Dispossession became historical process, not political choice
  • Organized knowledge — Surveys, ethnography, travel writing all reinforced the same message
  • Created identities — Anglo-Americans = agents of progress; Indigenous peoples = obstacles
  • Had material effects — Shaped policy, law, and physical transformation of landscapes

Art & Photography as Discursive Artifacts

Painting

Gast's American Progress (1872) doesn't just show Manifest Destiny—it constructs it as visual truth

  • Organizes space (light → dark)
  • Organizes time (one direction)
  • Assigns roles (agents vs. obstacles)

Photography

Survey photography claimed objectivity while carefully constructing the West

  • Emphasized resources & emptiness
  • Excluded Indigenous presence
  • Framing = discursive practice

Myth of the "Vanishing Indian" as Embedded Discourse

The Ideological Work

The myth of the vanishing Indian is a false, but influential story that claimed Native peoples were naturally disappearing, which helped justify U.S. expansion and hide the violence of removal, war, and assimilation.

  • Literature: Cooper's Last of the Mohicans — noble but doomed
  • Anthropology: "Salvage ethnography" assumed extinction was inevitable
  • Photography: Curtis staged "traditional" life as naturally fading
  • Effect: Transforms perpetrators into mourners; makes present Indigenous peoples "inauthentic"