HIST 101 · U.S. History to 1877 · Chapter 2

Historian's Notebook: Chapter 2

How England built colonies it never planned — and never fully controlled

Nothing saved yet

How to use this notebook

Complete activity spaces when prompted. Use the note areas only for evidence, explanations, examples, and questions that will help you reconstruct the lecture later. Your notes are not checked for completeness.

Manage Saved Work

Your work saves automatically in this browser on this device. It is not sent anywhere and does not follow you to another computer or phone. A backup file lets you move your work or keep a copy.

Start here

Chapter Inquiry


The question this chapter answers

Why did one nation's colonizing ventures produce several different Americas — and no single authority over any of them?

Lecture 1 argues that colonization happened where separate motives converged, not because England followed a plan. Lectures 2 and 3 show what happened next: goals, environments, migration streams, and labor systems turned English settlers into genuinely different colonial societies. Lecture 4 then asks who had the right to govern the result — and finds several claimants and no referee.

The lecture map

  1. Lecture 1Why Colonize?Convergence, not design
  2. Lecture 2Why Did the Colonies Become Different?Variables, not motives alone
  3. Lecture 3Building a Puritan SocietyPurpose, institutions, limits
  4. Lecture 4Who Controlled America?Authority claimed from three directions

Lecture 1

Why Colonize?


Guiding question

Why did England begin establishing permanent colonies in North America?

Argument to watch for

England colonized where several separate motives converged — and wanting a colony turned out to be very different from being able to keep one.

Section I · Religion Remade England

What happens to a country when it changes its church?

Notes go in this box. Fragments are fine — nobody is grading your handwriting.

Listen for: How did four monarchs in one generation make being English and being Protestant hard to separate? Why did Spain become the thing England defined itself against?

⏸ Pause & Reflect

Which connection between religion and colonization is strongest?

Choose one. Defend it in a sentence.

Your choice

Section II · Rivalry and Profit Pull England Outward

Why chase an empire that someone else has already built?

Your space. Arrows, abbreviations, and questionable spelling all welcome.

Listen for: Why was Spain's head start both a threat and an opportunity? How does one privateer earn three different verdicts at once? Where does 1588 actually belong in this story?

⏸ Pause & Predict

From raiding to lasting wealth

What you know
  • England can raid Spanish shipping successfully.
  • England wants lasting wealth from the Atlantic.

Section III · Wanting a Colony Is Not Having One

What does a permanent colony actually require?

Stash anything Future You will want. Future You forgets fast.

Listen for: What does a colony need that a raid does not? Why is Roanoke a failure of capacity rather than a mystery? And why would anyone leave England at all?

⏸ Different People, Different Motives

So what was the reason England colonized?

Match each person to a motive. Then complicate your own matches. Then answer the question.

Could the merchant also want Spain weakened? Could the Puritan family also want land? Could the Crown also care about trade?

Online hour — Independent Study: Why Roanoke failed · The case made for colonies · The Irish rehearsal · Leaving England.

Lecture 2

Why Did the Colonies Become Different?


Guiding question

If the settlers were English, why didn't all English colonies become the same kind of society?

Argument to watch for

Colonists did not reproduce England in America; goals, environment, migration, and labor turned English settlers into different colonial societies.

Section I · Virginia Began as a Business

What happens when a colony is founded to make money?

Type here. Full sentences strictly optional.

Listen for: What made a colony organized as an investment so badly organized for survival? And what was Tsenacommacah — what did the English actually walk into in 1607?

⏸ Pause & Reflect

Two readings of the same settlement

From the Virginia Company's perspective, Jamestown is an investment.

Section II · Tobacco Changes Everything

The relationship becomes far more dangerous once Virginia learns how to make money.

Scribble zone. Arrows encouraged, diagrams even better.

Listen for: How does one crop turn into six consequences? Why did economic success make conflict with Powhatan communities worse rather than better?

⏸ Pause & Predict

One profitable crop

The situation
  • A crop becomes enormously profitable.
  • It requires a great deal of land.
  • It requires a great many workers.

Section III · Labor Systems Build Different Societies

Who is going to do the work?

Big box, on purpose. Park whatever is worth keeping.

Listen for: What separated indentured servitude from slavery? How did colonial law make slavery lifelong, inheritable, and racial? How did Barbados run the same variables harder?

⏸ Predict the Colony

After thirty years, what differences would you expect?

Two colonies

Colony A

  • Warm climate
  • Profitable export crop
  • Mostly young migrants
  • Constant demand for workers
  • Settlement spreads outward for land

Colony B

  • Cooler climate
  • More family migration
  • Farms and towns
  • Less dependence on one export crop
One short prediction per cell.
DifferenceColony AColony B
Labor
Settlement and population
Land and wealth

Online hour — Independent Study: Jamestown's near-collapse · The Anglo-Powhatan Wars · 1619 and the historians · The Barbados sugar revolution.

Lecture 3

Building a Puritan Society


Guiding question

What happens when people cross an ocean not merely to practice a religion, but to organize an entire society around it?

Argument to watch for

Puritans crossed to build a godly community rather than simply to worship freely — which is why dissent inside that community proved so hard to tolerate.

Section I · A Religious Society, Not Just a Refuge

What did Pilgrims and Puritans actually want?

Notes here. Nobody reads this box but you.

Listen for: What separates Separatist Pilgrims from non-separating Puritans, and how small was Plymouth really? Why was the Mayflower Compact an urgent legal fix rather than the birth of democracy? What did the Wampanoag alliance offer each side?

⏸ Pause & Reflect

An alliance, read from the other side

Plymouth needed the Wampanoag alliance simply to survive its first years.

Section II · Belief Built the Society

What does a society look like when it is organized around religious purpose?

Free real estate for anything worth remembering.

Listen for: What did Winthrop carry across the ocean besides people? Why is a city upon a hill a warning rather than a boast? How far does covenant reach — family, congregation, town, school, government?

⏸ Build the Society

You believe God will judge your whole community by how faithfully it lives.

Which part of life would religion probably shape first?

Choose one

Section III · Truth Had Limits

What happens when someone inside the community says the community itself is wrong?

Write it down before it evaporates.

Listen for: What did Williams actually argue about conscience and coerced worship? What made Hutchinson's claim to direct revelation so dangerous? What does Rhode Island prove by contrast?

⏸ Freedom or Toleration?

Which better describes Massachusetts Bay?

Hold these apart

Religious freedom

Our community should be free to practice our religion.

Religious toleration

People who disagree should also be free to practice theirs.

Massachusetts Bay is better described by

Online hour — Independent Study: The Mayflower Compact myth · The Antinomian Controversy reconsidered · The Half-Way Covenant · Missions and the praying towns.

Lecture 4

Who Controlled America?


Guiding question

As English settlements expanded, who had the right to govern people and control land?

Argument to watch for

Seventeenth-century English America had several claimants to legitimate authority and no single center able to settle their conflicts.

Section I · Representation

Does electing representatives make a society democratic?

Your box, your rules. Bullet points are a perfectly respectable life choice.

Listen for: What did colonists bring from England, and what did distance add? What do the House of Burgesses, the Mayflower Compact, and the town meeting have in common? Who was shut out of all three?

⏸ Pause & Reflect

Were the English colonies becoming democratic?

Choose one and defend it.

Your choice

Section II · Sovereignty

What kind of political world did English settlers enter?

Toss the good stuff in here.

Listen for: Whose territories, councils, and diplomacy were already here? How did one agreement with Ousamequin get read two ways? Why is the Pequot War not a story of English versus Indians?

⏸ Pause & Predict

Two expanding claims, one piece of ground

The situation
  • English settlements keep growing.
  • Native nations keep governing their homelands.
  • Both need the same land.

Section III · Empire

What happens when the government that supposedly rules you collapses?

Last note box of the chapter. Send it off with something useful.

Listen for: What happened to imperial supervision while England fought a civil war and executed its king? After 1660, where did the Crown say assemblies came from, and where did colonists say they came from? What were proprietors handed six colonies to do?

⏸ Who Has Authority?

Put the three claims in one room

Three claims

English Crown

“We granted the colony.”

Colonists

“We govern our communities.”

Native nation

“This is our homeland.”

Online hour — Independent Study: Land as politics · Uncas and the politics of alliance · Carolina's design · New York's charter won and revoked.

Reference

Terms to Recognize and Use


You do not need to write definitions. Recognize these when you hear them, and use them when you explain the chapter. Each deck defines them in a pop-up.

Optional Chapter Review

This section is optional. It is not required for notebook completion, and nothing here is collected. Use it if it helps you consolidate the chapter.

Chapter organizer

The first two columns are given. Add the tension or consequence that followed — a phrase is enough.

Lecture 1 — Why Colonize?

Historical problem
England had reasons to expand long before it could sustain a colony.
Forces or claims
Religion, rivalry, profit, opportunity.

Lecture 2 — Why Did the Colonies Become Different?

Historical problem
English migrants built unlike societies on the same coast.
Forces or claims
Goals, environment, migration, labor.

Lecture 3 — Building a Puritan Society

Historical problem
A community organized around shared religious truth had to handle disagreement.
Forces or claims
Purpose, institutions, limits.

Lecture 4 — Who Controlled America?

Historical problem
Several communities claimed the right to govern the same people and land.
Forces or claims
Representation, sovereignty, empire.

Retrieval

Answer from memory first, then check the deck or your notes.

Synthesis

Muddiest point

I can explain…

Where the chapter leaves you

Chapter 2 does not end with a winner. Colonists, Native nations, proprietors, and the Crown all held claims that looked legitimate from the inside, and those claims collided as settlement expanded. Next: Stream & Discuss: Massacre at Mystic.

This notebook saves your work in this browser on this device only. Nothing is sent anywhere. Clearing your browser data will erase it — use Download Backup under Manage Saved Work if you want a copy you can keep or move.